Can We Price It High and Come Down Later?

I hear this one at almost every listing appointment, usually about thirty seconds after I slide the pricing analysis across the table. The logic sounds airtight. Nobody is going to pay more than the house is worth, so what is the harm in starting a little high? If it does not sell, we come down. No downside.

Here is my answer: you can, the market will let you, and it will usually cost you money. It costs you because of how buyers behave in the first two weeks a house is on the market, and because of what a price cut tells the buyers who come later. I will walk through both, then give you the rule I use to decide, by day fourteen, whether a price is working.

The first two weeks are the only free advantage you get

The morning your listing hits the MLS, it goes out to every buyer with a saved search that matches it. Most of those buyers have been looking for months. They know what a $700,000 house on the east side of Libertyville looks like inside, because they have already walked through six of them.

When your house shows up at $750,000 with $700,000 finishes, those buyers do not call to negotiate. They do not write a low offer. They just do not book a showing. Nothing happens. And nothing is the expensive part, because the only time a listing is new is once.

Why “come down later” is not a neutral move

Price history is public. Every portal shows the original list price, every reduction, and the days-on-market counter. A buyer who finds your house at day 48 with one price cut does not read that as “motivated seller, let’s go see it.” They read it as “other people already passed on this,” and they start wondering what they are missing. Then they offer accordingly.

So the buyer who shows up after the reduction negotiates harder than the buyer who would have shown up in week one at the right number. In my experience the seller often lands below where correct pricing would have put them, and carried the house two extra months to get there. You are trading your strongest position for your weakest one.

The fourteen-day showing count

This is the rule I use. It is a rule of thumb from my own listings, not a published statistic, and the exact numbers shift with price point and season. But the pattern holds.

Count showings and offers for the first fourteen days. Then read the result like this:

  • Steady showings and at least one offer: the price is right. Negotiate from strength.
  • Steady showings, no offers: buyers like the house enough to visit but think it is worth a bit less. This is usually a small gap, a few percent. A modest adjustment fixes it.
  • Few or no showings: the house is not making the first cut online. Buyers are filtering it out before they ever see the kitchen. That is a bigger gap, or a presentation problem, or both.

The decision happens at day fourteen. Not day thirty. Not “let’s give it through the holidays.” By month two, the fix costs more, because now you are fighting the days-on-market counter as well as the price.

Mind the search brackets

Buyers search in ranges, and most set a ceiling at a round number: up to $600,000, up to $700,000, up to $800,000. A house listed at $710,000 is invisible to everyone whose search stops at $700,000, and competes against houses up to $800,000 for everyone else. Worst of both worlds.

If the comps say $700,000, list at $700,000 and show up in both searches. “Testing” ten or fifteen thousand above a bracket line is the most common version of pricing high I see, and the most expensive, because it hides the house from the buyers most likely to want it.

“But what if we leave money on the table?”

Fair follow-up. Here is the asymmetry. If the house is worth more than the comps suggest, buyers will tell you with their offers, and in the first two weeks they will tell you loudly. A well-priced house creates competition, and competition pushes the number up. An overpriced house never creates competition. It just waits. Pricing at the comps protects the downside and still lets the upside happen.

One question to ask any agent who agrees with the high number

Some agents will tell you what you want to hear to win the listing. The industry calls it buying the listing: take it high, then work you down over ninety days. If an agent nods along with a number well above what the others proposed, ask one thing: show me three closed sales from the last six months that support that price. Not actives, not pendings. Closed. If they cannot, they are guessing with your money.

If timing is on your mind too, I wrote about what really happens when you list a Libertyville home in winter. Fewer buyers, but serious ones, which makes the opening price matter even more.

If you want a second opinion on a number, or you want to see the comps I would use for your house, I am always available to talk real estate. Call or text me at 847-650-4048.

Leave a Reply