Yes to a New Meadow Plaza. No to Pulte’s Plan.

I don’t live in Northbrook. I don’t pay Northbrook property taxes, and I don’t get a vote on Meadow Plaza. However, I grew up next door in Glenview, I live a few exits up the Tollway in Libertyville, and I help people buy and sell homes in Northbrook. So I have a front-row seat, if not a ticket.

I’m also a Realtor, and somewhere in the oath I never actually took, there’s a line about never turning down 150 new units. Consider this my resignation from a club that doesn’t exist. I’m against this plan, completely.

That isn’t because Meadow Plaza should stay frozen in 1960-something. It shouldn’t. The owner has tried to sell it for about a decade, and according to the village’s own consultant, none of the fifteen written offers proposed keeping the center as it is. Something new is going to happen on that corner. The question is whether Northbrook gets something worthy of its downtown or something off a national builder’s shelf.

Pulte’s plan is the shelf version.

Where things stand

On November 17, after four nights of hearings, Northbrook’s Plan Commission closed the public hearing and took a straw poll on Pulte’s revised plan. It was 8 to 0 against. The formal vote is set for Wednesday, December 2, at 7:30 PM. The commission’s recommendation then goes to the Village Board, which makes the final call.

So this isn’t over. A unanimous straw poll is a strong signal, but the board decides, and pressure from a national builder doesn’t stop with one commission vote.

What’s on the table

Pulte wants to demolish the 90,000 square foot shopping center and put up three six-story condo buildings, 50 units each, about 68 feet tall. Downtown zoning allows four stories by right and five with a special permit. Back in 2018, the Plan Commission itself said five stories was appropriate for Meadow Plaza. Pulte is asking for six.

In my opinion, that’s too tall. Some people see six stories as fine if it’s tucked in the right spot. I don’t think three 68-foot buildings fit the scale of Northbrook’s downtown anywhere on that site, and at least one commissioner agreed, calling six stories “way too high.”

Commercial space would drop from about 90,000 square feet to about 12,500. That’s an 85% cut in the retail at the center of downtown, on land zoned commercial. And the target pricing the village has shared is $600,000 to $1,000,000 per unit. Premium prices can be justified. Premium prices for a template can’t.

A national template wearing a Northbrook name tag

Look at the renderings. Three nearly identical boxes. Nothing about them says Northbrook. Put them in Naperville, Schaumburg or a suburb of Columbus and nobody would notice the difference.

Making a project feel like it belongs takes time and money: real architecture, real materials, a site plan that works with the river and the street instead of just fitting around them. Pulte’s plan reads like they decided that work wasn’t worth it. That’s a business decision, and it tells you how much they care about this place. You don’t get to cut corners in the middle of someone else’s downtown.

The revision made it worse

After hundreds of residents packed the hearings, Pulte came back with changes. Here’s what the November revision did:

  • Removed the riverwalk. The public waterfront amenity they’d been selling is gone, along with the pond, the pergola and the walking path.
  • Cut residential parking, from 203 spaces in the original submittal to 168 in the new narrative, about 1.1 per unit.
  • Added a “Village Square” with 11 micro-shops. Most are 120 square feet, about the size of a kid’s bedroom. Testimony at the hearing described them as seasonal, with no running water and no bathroom. The restrooms are a standalone shared building, basically a glorified outhouse. Pulte would build all of it and then donate it to the village to operate and maintain. In other words, Northbrook taxpayers become the landlord of tiny retail stalls that Pulte doesn’t want to own.

That isn’t a response to the community. It’s a sweetener added in a hurry, with the long-term cost shifted onto the village. Even the commission chair said this kind of program belongs to a commercial developer and its management team, not the village.

Who gets left behind

Meadow Plaza has 14 businesses, some of them operating for decades. The village’s own consultant estimates new downtown commercial space would rent for $35 to $45 per square foot. The cobbler, the dry cleaner and the gift shop that’s been there 20 years aren’t moving into that. “We’re adding commercial space” sounds good until you ask who can afford it.

Pulte has run this play before

This isn’t Pulte’s first mixed-use pitch, and it wouldn’t be the first time a town that said no or set terms ended up fighting about it afterward.

In Fairfax County, Virginia, Pulte was part of MetroWest, a big project next to a Metro station that was approved in 2006. The approval came with commitments: density limits, a construction schedule, and public amenities like a community center, a seasonal skating rink and a town square. The condos got built. The town center stalled. Over the years the developers came back for changes: swapping planned multistory buildings for single-story retail, lifting the cap that held back more housing until the town center broke ground, and eventually getting the county to drop the office requirement entirely. Sixteen years after approval, the “town center” was still a negotiation.

To be fair, the town center was Pulte’s partner’s piece. That’s exactly the point. When the housing and the “downtown” are separate pieces, the housing gets built and the downtown becomes a promise.

In Orion Township, Michigan, near Pulte’s own hometown, the planning commission recommended against a Pulte development and the township board said no. Pulte and the landowner sued the township, arguing the denial was a pretext to block residential development. The case ended in a court-ordered settlement, and the land became a 343-home Pulte subdivision.

Closer to home, a downtown Lisle project was supposed to be mixed-use. Once Pulte was involved, it became townhomes. One planning commissioner summed it up: “Where’s the mixed use? We won’t have it.”

Meadow Plaza’s revised plan has the same shape: 150 condos, a little commercial space, and a Village Square handed off to the village. The part Pulte sells gets built, and the downtown part is someone else’s problem.

Northbrook holds the cards

Here’s the difference between Meadow Plaza and a golf course in Michigan. Pulte isn’t asking Northbrook to approve something the code already allows. It’s asking for major exceptions: a sixth story the zoning doesn’t permit, and a residential project on land zoned for commerce, at the center of the downtown commercial district. Exceptions like that are the village’s to grant, not the developer’s to demand.

That’s where Northbrook should hold firm. Be deliberate about when you bend the rules and why, and make a developer earn every exception with something the town actually wants. A national builder that has sued a township before isn’t a reason to give in. It’s a reason to make sure every no is clearly grounded in the code and the village’s own plans. Northbrook is not the kind of town that hands over its downtown because someone might call a lawyer.

A word to my fellow Realtors

I’ve heard that Realtors in the area are pro-development. I believe it, and so do the residents, which is part of why they’ve stopped listening to us.

I get the math. One hundred fifty transactions is a real number. But take it apart. A big share of those buyers will come through Pulte’s own sales team, with no agent involved. The rest get split across every brokerage on the North Shore. By the time the pie is cut, most of us get a sliver or nothing at all, and we’d be trading the town’s goodwill for it.

Being a Realtor doesn’t mean cheering for every real estate proposal that comes along. Our clients trust us to know what makes a town valuable. Character, walkability and a downtown people actually want to spend time in are what hold Northbrook home values up. If you want more housing in Northbrook, and I do, push for a better plan. You can get the units without endorsing this one.

What I’ve learned from living near good downtowns

I’m not a planner, and I don’t have the plan for Meadow Plaza. Anyone who claims to have the perfect answer is selling something. But I live a few blocks from downtown Libertyville, and I watched Glenview reinvent itself growing up. A few things are obvious from the outside.

Downtown Libertyville works because people have a reason to be there that isn’t errands. There are events, restaurants and the kind of storefronts you walk past just to see what’s new. It also has MainStreet Libertyville, an independent group whose whole job is downtown events, marketing and support for local businesses. Northbrook doesn’t have an equivalent, and its own Economic Strategy Commission has recommended creating one.

Glenview, meanwhile, showed what it looks like when the village takes the wheel. When the old Bess Hardware site downtown needed a future, the village bought it and controlled what came next. You can argue about the result, but Glenview wasn’t just reacting to whatever a builder brought in.

So here’s what I’d want if Meadow Plaza were in my town:

1. The village leads, and residents choose. Set design standards for the site, put out a request for proposals, get several competing concepts, and let residents weigh in before anything goes to a vote. Start with an honest number: one commissioner urged the Village Board to pay for an independent study of what’s actually financially viable on the site. I’d second that. You can’t negotiate well if the only economics on the table are the developer’s.

2. The right scale. Three or four stories, a mix of rowhouse-style condos and mixed-use buildings, from a builder who designs for this site. There’s real demand from empty nesters who want to stay in Northbrook without the house. Serve them without overpowering the block.

3. Commercial up front, designed as one place. The commission chair described a version he’d support: drop the condo building at Cherry and Meadow and redevelop the whole front of the site as a cohesive commercial district of smaller buildings, with a central space for the farmers market. That’s close to what I’d want. Build it as one connected place, not a few individual buildings.

4. A permanent home for the farmers market. It’s already the most-loved thing about Meadow Plaza. A year-round market hall with food vendors, local makers and event space gives people a reason to come downtown in February, not just in July.

5. Phasing that keeps legacy tenants. Don’t let downtown go dark for two years. Build in stages and give the businesses that have been there for decades a real path to stay.

6. Use the river. A real riverwalk, the one Pulte just cut, gives downtown something no strip center in the northwest suburbs has.

7. A downtown business association. A Northbrook version of MainStreet Libertyville would give residents and business owners an organized seat at the table the next time a developer shows up.

The bottom line

It’s not my town, so take this from the guy one exit up the Tollway. But I’ve lived around these downtowns my whole life, and the towns that get it right don’t take the first plan a national builder slides across the table.

If I had a vote, it would be no, on December 2 and at the Village Board after that. Northbrook should redevelop Meadow Plaza on its own terms, with a plan that looks like it was designed for Northbrook rather than picked off a shelf.


Sources

Leave a Reply