What $650,000 Buys in Libertyville vs. Mundelein vs. Vernon Hills

I get a version of this question almost every week. Someone has a budget in mind, usually somewhere between $450,000 and $700,000, and they want to know whether Libertyville is worth the premium over the towns that touch it. Mundelein shares a border with us. Vernon Hills is a few minutes down Milwaukee Avenue. So why does the Libertyville price tag look so different?

Here are the numbers first, then what the numbers hide.

The September numbers

According to Redfin’s September 2026 data, the median sale price in Libertyville was $647,692, down 4.1% from a year earlier. Ninety-nine homes closed, median days on market was 52, and the average sale came in at 100.3% of list price.

Mundelein’s September median was $406,796, up 0.7% year over year, with 127 homes sold, 46 median days on market, and a sale-to-list ratio of 99.9%.

Vernon Hills’ most recent full month on Redfin is June 2026: a median of $460,749, up 0.7%, 94 homes sold, 44 days on market, and sales at 100.1% of list.

On paper, Libertyville costs about $240,000 more than Mundelein and about $190,000 more than Vernon Hills. That is the number people quote to me. It is also mostly wrong.

Why the medians lie

A town’s median sale price is the middle of every closing, and every closing includes condos and townhomes. Mundelein and Vernon Hills have a lot of attached housing. Libertyville has comparatively little. When a third of your sales are $250,000 townhomes, your median drops, and it says nothing about what a four-bedroom detached house on a half-acre costs.

Compare like for like, a detached two-story on a similar lot, and the Libertyville premium is real but much smaller than $240,000. In many pockets it is closer to 10 to 15 percent, and in some it disappears entirely.

The same logic explains the “down 4.1%” headline. Libertyville did not lose four percent of its value in a year. Sales volume was up almost 15%, and buyers were paying over asking on average. Prices do not fall while people are bidding above list. What changed is the mix of what sold: more mid-priced homes closed this September than last, and the median moved with them. If you own in Libertyville and that headline made you nervous, it should not.

What the same money actually buys

Take $650,000 and shop all three towns. Here is what I see on the MLS every week.

In Libertyville, that budget gets you a 1960s to 1980s two-story or split-level on the west side, usually with a solid lot and mature trees, often with original windows and a kitchen that has been updated once. Closer to downtown it buys less house and more location: an older, smaller home where a good share of the price is the dirt it sits on.

In Mundelein, the same money gets you a newer and larger house. Think a 1990s or 2000s build with a three-car garage, more square footage, and mechanicals that are not on their last legs. You will likely be a drive from a downtown rather than a walk.

In Vernon Hills, $650,000 is comfortably above the median, so you get the better end of the town’s 1980s and 1990s two-stories, typically in good condition, with the lower maintenance that newer construction brings. Vernon Hills also has a townhome and condo market that Libertyville barely offers, which matters if you are downsizing.

What you are paying for in Libertyville

Three things, in my opinion. First, a real downtown. Milwaukee Avenue through the center of town is a destination, and homes within walking distance of it carry a premium that has held through every market I have worked in. Second, land. The older sections of town were platted with bigger lots and the trees have had seventy years to grow. Third, scarcity. Libertyville does not add much new housing, so supply stays tight and values stay sticky.

What you give up is age. The housing stock is older, so the per-square-foot cost is higher and the deferred maintenance list is longer. If you buy a 1970s house here, assume you are the one replacing the roof, the windows, or the furnace at some point, and price that in.

One more factor: trains. Libertyville and Mundelein sit on the Milwaukee District North line. Vernon Hills is on the North Central Service, which runs fewer trains. If you ride downtown every day, that difference shows up in your life long after the purchase price stops mattering.

My honest take

Do not buy a town name. Buy a specific house on a specific street. I have watched people pay the Libertyville premium for a house on the far edge of town that is a fifteen-minute drive from anything, when the same house a half mile away in Mundelein would have cost them less and changed nothing about their daily life. I have also watched people “save” money in a neighboring town and then spend every weekend driving back to Libertyville because that is where they actually wanted to be.

Figure out which one you are before you write an offer. If you want to walk through the actual comps for a specific street, I am always available to talk real estate. Call or text me at 847-650-4048.

Town guides

Current listings, neighborhood notes and market data for each town: Libertyville real estate, Mundelein real estate and Vernon Hills real estate.

Frequently asked questions

Is Libertyville more expensive than Mundelein?

On paper, yes. Libertyville’s September 2026 median sale price was about $648,000 versus about $407,000 in Mundelein. But Mundelein’s median includes far more condos and townhomes. Compare a detached two-story on a similar lot and the Libertyville premium is usually closer to 10 to 15 percent.

What does $650,000 buy in Libertyville?

Typically a 1960s to 1980s two-story or split-level on the west side with a good lot and mature trees, or a smaller, older home closer to downtown where more of the price is the land.

Why did Libertyville’s median price drop 4.1 percent?

Because of the mix of what sold, not falling values. Sales volume was up almost 15 percent and homes sold at an average of 100.3 percent of list price. More mid-priced homes closed this September than last, which pulled the median down.

Which town has the better train commute?

Libertyville and Mundelein are on Metra’s Milwaukee District North line. Vernon Hills is on the North Central Service, which runs fewer trains. Daily commuters usually notice the difference.


About the author

Joe Gattone is a real estate broker with Compass in Libertyville, Illinois, serving Lake County and Chicago’s North Shore and Northwest suburbs. He has been selling in and around Libertyville for more than 13 years, closed 29 transactions in 2025, and ranked third among Libertyville agents by sales volume. Most of his business comes from referrals and repeat clients. He writes Broker Approved to explain how real estate actually works in Libertyville, Lake Forest, Mundelein, Vernon Hills and the surrounding towns.

More about Joe Gattone · Compass profile · Libertyville real estate · Call or text 847-650-4048

Leave a Reply